Two teens on opposite sides of time are bound by a mission to stop a future catastrophe—if they can outwit the forces that keep pulling them together and tearing history apart. All Our Yesterdays is a taut, time-twisting thriller about love, sacrifice, and second chances.
Have you read this book? Share what you liked (or didn’t) and get personalized recommendations.
Start or resume Shelf TalkThese picks are popular with readers who enjoyed this book. Possible spoilers below.
In All Our Yesterdays, did you enjoy the high-stakes time-jump mission to rewrite a catastrophic future?
If you were hooked by Em and Finn using Cassandra to jump back and stop James before he becomes Doc—and the desperate note-in-the-drain urgency of “You have to kill him” —you’ll tear through Tempest. Jackson Meyer’s time-jumping spirals into a conspiracy after his girlfriend is attacked, forcing him to leap again and again to fix a future unraveling around him. The split-second choices, the countdown feel, and the aching romance under fire echo the pulse and stakes you loved in All Our Yesterdays.
In All Our Yesterdays, did you enjoy protagonists crossing moral lines to stop the monster they helped create?
Em’s decision to assassinate James—someone she once loved as Marina—mirrors the razor-edged ethics in Vicious. As Victor Vale hunts his former friend Eli, both men justify terrible means to stop a greater threat, much like Em weighing one life against a broken future ruled by Doc. If the way All Our Yesterdays wrestles with love, guilt, and the cost of doing what’s necessary gripped you, this morally charged cat-and-mouse will, too.
In All Our Yesterdays, did you enjoy a twisty, time-bending structure where each pass reframes the truth?
Loved how alternating Em/Marina chapters slowly reveal that they’re the same person—and how every return to the past reshapes what you think of James/Doc? The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle traps Aiden Bishop in a looping day and different hosts, each repetition peeling back new layers of the mystery. That same mind-bending structure and “aha!” rush you got as All Our Yesterdays recontextualized its timelines is front and center here.
In All Our Yesterdays, did you enjoy breakneck, on-the-run stakes powered by dual viewpoints?
If Em and Finn’s prison break, constant pursuit, and high-stakes urban chases kept you flipping pages—and you liked how Em/Marina’s dual perspectives ratcheted tension—Legend delivers that adrenaline. June and Day pursue and outwit each other across a ruthless Republic, trading perspective every chapter as revelations slam into action. It captures the same kinetic, knife’s-edge momentum you felt racing to stop Doc’s rise.
In All Our Yesterdays, did you enjoy reality-warping reveals that recontextualize everything you’ve read?
If the Em/Marina identity reveal and the true scope of Doc’s future made your stomach drop, Dark Matter will scratch that itch. Jason Dessen is yanked out of his life and into a version of reality that turns every assumption inside out; each twist forces him to confront who he is and what he’s willing to do—much like Em facing the cost of stopping James. It’s a relentless cascade of reveals with the emotional punch you loved.
